Q&A – How to Reduce Sugar

The Feeding Your Kids Foundation operates an international program to teach parents how to feed their children healthier and teach their children to have a healthier attitude toward food. It is entirely free to parents everywhere in the world. The program will help you, day by day over time, to build the skills you and your child need. Here are a few questions that are covered step by step in the program:

Q&A - How Much Sugar Should Kids Have and How Do I Reduce It?

Managing children’s sugar intake requires understanding both the hidden sources of added sugars and the difference between naturally occurring and processed sweeteners. Children currently get 20-33% of their calories from various forms of sugar, far exceeding the American Heart Association’s recommendation of no more than 16 grams daily for children.

The goal isn’t eliminating all sweetness but rather controlling added sugars while maintaining the natural enjoyment of sweet tastes through whole foods and natural alternatives.

How Much Sugar Should Children Actually Consume?

American Heart Association recommendations:

  • Children 2-18 years: No more than 16 grams (4 teaspoons) of added sugar per day
  • Children under 2 years: No added sugars at all
  • Focus on limiting “added sugars” rather than naturally occurring sugars in whole fruits

Put this in perspective:

  • One 12-oz soda contains about 39 grams of sugar (nearly 10 teaspoons)
  • Many children’s cereals contain 12-20 grams per serving
  • A single flavored yogurt cup may contain 15-25 grams
  • Many children exceed daily recommendations at breakfast alone

Why these limits matter:

  • Excessive sugar intake is linked to childhood obesity, dental problems, and behavior issues
  • High sugar consumption can interfere with nutrient absorption
  • Sugar preferences developed in childhood often persist into adulthood
  • Blood sugar spikes and crashes affect mood, attention, and energy levels

Where Is Sugar Hiding in My Child’s Diet?

Unexpected sources of added sugar:

  • Bread and crackers: Many contain high fructose corn syrup
  • Pasta sauces and ketchup: Often loaded with added sugars
  • Chicken nuggets and processed meats: Frequently contain multiple forms of sugar
  • Salad dressings and condiments: Major hidden sugar sources
  • “Healthy” snacks: Granola bars, fruit snacks, and yogurt drinks

How to identify hidden sugars on labels:
Sugar appears under many names: glucose, fructose, sucrose, lactose, dextrose, maltose, fruit juice concentrate, high fructose corn syrup, rice syrup, honey, agave, maple syrup, and more.

Label reading strategy:

  • Ingredients are listed by quantity, so sugar in the first few ingredients means high sugar content
  • Add up all sugar-related ingredients to get the true sugar picture
  • Compare similar products and choose those with less total sugar
  • Look for products with no artificial sweeteners, which can maintain sugar cravings

How Do I Reduce Sugar Without My Child Noticing?

Gradual reduction strategies:

  • Remove 1/3 of sugar from baking recipes – most children won’t notice the difference
  • Dilute sweet drinks progressively until children accept less sweetness
  • Mix sugary cereals with unsweetened whole grain versions, gradually changing the ratio
  • Transition from flavored to plain yogurt by mixing in fresh fruit

Natural sweetness enhancement:

  • Use spices like cinnamon, vanilla, or cocoa to create sweet associations without added sugar
  • Incorporate naturally sweet vegetables like roasted carrots, sweet potatoes, or beets
  • Add fresh or dried fruits to cereals, oatmeal, and baked goods
  • Use natural fruit purees in baking to reduce refined sugar needs

Cooking and baking modifications:

  • Replace half the flour in baked goods with whole grain alternatives to slow sugar absorption
  • Add fiber-rich ingredients (oats, nuts, seeds) to cookies and muffins
  • Use unsweetened applesauce or mashed banana to replace some sugar in recipes
  • Experiment with natural sweeteners like pure maple syrup or raw honey (not for children under 1 year)

What Are Natural Alternatives to Refined Sugar?

Better sweetener options (in moderation):

  • Pure maple syrup: Contains minerals and has less impact on blood sugar than refined sugar
  • Raw honey: Provides enzymes and antioxidants (never for children under 12 months)
  • Unsweetened applesauce or fruit purees: Add natural sweetness plus fiber
  • Dates: Can be pureed into a paste for baking
  • Whole fruit: Provides sweetness with fiber, vitamins, and minerals

Why natural alternatives are better:

  • They often contain beneficial nutrients lacking in refined sugar
  • They’re typically less processed
  • They may have less dramatic effects on blood sugar levels
  • They help children develop appreciation for more complex flavors

Important caveat: Natural sweeteners still contribute to total sugar intake and should be used moderately. The goal is developing taste preferences that don’t require intense sweetness.

How Do I Handle Birthday Parties and Special Occasions?

Balanced approach to celebrations:

  • Allow treats at special occasions without guilt or restrictions
  • Focus on portion control rather than complete avoidance
  • Teach children that celebration foods are “sometimes” foods
  • Model enjoying treats in moderation

Strategies for parties and events:

  • Send your child with a healthy snack beforehand so they’re not extremely hungry
  • Contribute healthy options to parties when possible
  • Allow your child to choose one sweet treat rather than sampling everything
  • Focus on the social aspects of celebrations rather than just the food

Creating new traditions:

  • Celebrate with special activities, not just special foods
  • Make homemade treats using healthier ingredients for family celebrations
  • Involve children in preparing celebration foods so they understand ingredients
  • Create positive associations with nutritious foods during special times

Should I Eliminate Sugar Completely?

Complete elimination is not recommended and may backfire:

  • Forbidden foods often become more appealing to children
  • Complete restriction can lead to sneaking behaviors or binge eating when sugar is available
  • Children need to learn to manage sweet foods in moderation
  • Social isolation may occur if children can never participate in typical childhood food experiences

Balanced restriction approach:

  • Establish clear guidelines about “everyday” vs. “sometimes” foods
  • Allow controlled portions of sweet treats rather than unlimited access
  • Teach children to recognize how different foods make their bodies feel
  • Focus on adding nutritious foods rather than only removing sweet ones

Teaching moderation:

  • Help children recognize physical cues of satisfaction
  • Discuss how sugar affects energy, mood, and concentration
  • Practice savoring smaller amounts of high-quality treats
  • Model balanced eating behaviors yourself

How Do I Deal With Sugar Cravings and Tantrums?

Understanding sugar cravings:

  • Blood sugar spikes followed by crashes create physiological cravings for more sugar
  • Habit and emotional associations can drive sugar desires beyond physical needs
  • Artificial colors and flavors in high-sugar foods may contribute to behavioral issues
  • Irregular meal timing can intensify sugar cravings

Reducing cravings through nutrition:

  • Provide balanced meals and snacks that include protein and fiber
  • Maintain regular meal times to prevent extreme hunger
  • Ensure adequate sleep, as tired children often crave sugar for quick energy
  • Address any underlying nutritional deficiencies

Managing tantrums and resistance:

  • Stay calm and consistent with established sugar policies
  • Offer choices between acceptable alternatives rather than arguing about denied requests
  • Redirect attention to activities when possible
  • Remember that taste preferences change gradually with consistent exposure to less sweet foods

How Long Does It Take to Reduce Sugar Preferences?

Timeline for taste adaptation:

  • 2-3 weeks: Children may begin accepting less sweet versions of familiar foods
  • 1-2 months: Significant reduction in sugar cravings and preference for intensely sweet foods
  • 3-6 months: New taste preferences become established and feel normal
  • Long-term: Children may find previously enjoyed high-sugar foods too sweet

Signs of progress:

  • Less begging for sweet snacks between meals
  • Willingness to try fruits and vegetables without added sweeteners
  • Improved energy stability throughout the day
  • Better appetite for balanced meals
  • Comments that previously enjoyed sweet foods now taste “too sweet”

Patience during transition:
Children accustomed to high-sugar diets may initially resist changes. Consistent exposure to less sweet foods, combined with positive associations and family modeling, will gradually shift preferences toward more balanced tastes.

Supporting the process:

  • Celebrate small victories and gradual improvements
  • Focus on how healthy eating makes children feel rather than restrictions
  • Include children in cooking and food preparation to build investment in healthier choices
  • Remember that establishing healthy relationships with food is a long-term process

The Feeding Your Kids program emphasizes that reducing sugar intake is about creating sustainable eating patterns that children can maintain throughout their lives, rather than short-term dietary restrictions that may lead to problematic relationships with food.

Click to access the login or register cheese